ContentOne of the most important campaigns for anti-smoking activists is raising the effective price of cigarettes by encouraging a “sin tax” from individual states. But does raising the actual cost of a pack of cigarettes deter smoking?
The cost of a pack of cigarettes obviously will vary widely from brand to brand and from store to store. Additionally, individual states in the United States are all over the map when it comes to cigarette tax, which can vary from less than 50 cents to more than four dollars, which adds to the price of a pack of cigarettes.
For instance Missouri has the lowest cigarette state tax in the nation at 17 cents per pack of cigarettes and round out the top five of states that have the highest percentage of adult smokers. This would seem to indicate that a lower tax on cigarettes lead to a higher percentage of smokers. But New York, which has the highest per pack cigarette tax in the nation at $4.35 but sit almost exactly in the middle when it comes to percentage of adult smokers there. If half the nation smokes more than the highest-taxed people in the United States, how effective can raising the price of cigarettes really be?
Turns out, New York is an outlier. While the numbers don’t correlate perfectly, most states that charge a higher tax for cigarettes have a lower percentage of adult smokers in their population. Take the second highest taxer, as an example. The state of Rhode Island charges smokers an extra $3.46 for every pack and less than a handful of states can boast to have less smokers than them. The third highest taxer is Washington at $3.02 a pack and has the same claim to fame (they are the 47th state when it comes to population of adult smokers).
It’s pretty clear that emphasizing (and trying to raise) the money that is coming directly out of the pocket of the consumer may be the best way to reduce smoking rates.









